Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

SMAR Daily Industry News

Daily news across AI, technology, finance, insurance, healthcare, automotive, real estate, and government

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

Former CA Insurance Judge Sues Over Rate Approval Process

📅 2026-11-11 | 📰 Insurance Business America
#california insurance #proposition 103 #rate increases #administrative law judge #insurance regulation

A lawsuit filed in Alameda County Superior Court alleges that the California Department of Insurance pressured its former chief administrative law judge, Kristin Rosi, to overturn a ruling that required independent judicial review of insurance rate-increase settlements. Rosi, who served from 2016 until her dismissal in 2025, claims Commissioner Ricardo Lara and former special counsel Lucy Wang forced her to change the decision and terminated her when she refused.

Rosi’s original October 2024 ruling held that the department’s practice of approving homeowner and auto insurer rate hikes through negotiated settlements violated Proposition 103, which mandates prior departmental approval and, when a consumer group requests a hearing, a public hearing before any increase is approved. She argued that settlements still needed an ALJ’s sign-off to confirm fairness. The insurance industry contested the ruling, and Lara partially vacated it, citing alleged legal errors cited by the department’s Rate Enforcement Bureau.

According to the complaint, Wang and senior officials subsequently limited the types of cases the Administrative Hearing Bureau could consider and Lara emailed Rosi urging her to adopt a plan that would allow judges to review settlements only after a formal notice of hearing had been issued. Additional complaints filed with the California State Bar allege that Wang and, in at least one instance, Lara held ex parte meetings with the department’s legal team about pending cases, excluding insurers and intervenors, a breach that could be deemed improper in court.

Wang now works for a San Francisco law firm representing insurers and declined comment, citing representation by the attorney general’s office. The attorney general’s office deferred to the Insurance Department. The Administrative Hearing Bureau currently has a single judge, who in August 2026 noted the branch’s understaffing and resource constraints. Former commissioner Dave Jones, who appointed Rosi, described the allegations as “shocking and disturbing,” emphasizing the need for the commissioner to be insulated from departmental influence when making final decisions.

The dispute has implications for California’s property market, where rising wildfire risk has driven double-digit homeowner rate increases for major carriers. If the settlements Rosi challenged indeed bypassed required judicial oversight, the rates paid by consumers may not meet Proposition 103’s standards. Consumer Federation of California executive director Robert Herrell, a former deputy commissioner, called Rosi “smart, serious and well-respected,” noting that administrative judges often favor the insurance industry.

Jane Kim, who won the November 3 election to succeed Lara, said through a spokesperson that she will investigate the claims after taking office in January. The lawsuit’s first case management conference is set for February 16 2027.

Why it matters

The case could reshape how California insurance rates are approved, affecting premiums for homeowners and auto policyholders.

FAQ

Who filed the lawsuit against the California Department of Insurance?
Former chief administrative law judge Kristin Rosi filed the lawsuit in Alameda County Superior Court.

What does Proposition 103 require for insurance rate increases?
Proposition 103 requires prior departmental approval and a public hearing when a consumer group requests one before a rate increase can be approved.

What actions does the lawsuit allege were taken against Rosi?
The lawsuit alleges that Commissioner Ricardo Lara and special counsel Lucy Wang pressured Rosi to change her ruling, limited case intake, and that Lara emailed her to adopt a restricted review plan.

When is the first case management conference scheduled?
The first case management conference is scheduled for February 16, 2027.

Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.