Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

SMAR Daily Industry News

Daily news across AI, technology, finance, insurance, healthcare, automotive, real estate, and government

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

CHOICE Health Arrangements: State-by-State Viability Analysis

📅 2026-11-12 | 📰 Insurance Business America
#choice #ichra #wakely consulting #aca marketplace #health insurance

A recent white paper from Wakely Consulting Group, an HMA Company, suggests that the financial feasibility of Custom Health Option and Individual Care Expense (CHOICE) arrangements—formerly known as individual coverage health reimbursement arrangements (ICHRA)—is highly dependent on the specific state where an employer operates. The October 2026 report, authored by actuaries Taylor Gehrke, Michael Cohen, and Kayla Zimdars, emphasizes that findings cannot be broadly extrapolated across different regions due to significant variations in how individual ACA and small group ACA premiums align.

The analysis modeled adoption scenarios across South Carolina, Iowa, and Tennessee. In South Carolina, where the paper estimates individual ACA premiums are at least 50% higher than small group ACA in 2027, the researchers project that individual ACA enrollment could rise between 2.4% and 7.6% if small employers transition to CHOICE, contingent on the required premium savings threshold. Conversely, in Tennessee, where individual ACA premiums are also estimated to be at least 50% higher than small group ACA, the authors conclude that significant adoption is unlikely, regardless of other incentives.

Iowa presents a different dynamic, as the pricing between the two markets is much closer. In this state, the projected enrollment impact ranges from 0.0% to 0.3%. The study highlights that when a $50-per-employee-per-month vendor fee is included, the premium savings advantage in Iowa effectively vanishes. Wakely notes that this fee is consistent with pricing from at least one CHOICE platform administrator, suggesting that in markets where premiums are nearly equivalent, such administrative costs can render the model uncompetitive without further tax incentives.

The report also addresses the potential impact on the individual ACA risk pool. In South Carolina, the modeling estimates that individual ACA morbidity could improve by 0.5% to 1.5% if employer-covered workers join the pool, assuming these employees are healthier than current enrollees. However, if healthier employer groups choose level-funded alternatives instead, the risk pool could deteriorate, potentially driving up premiums for all individual ACA enrollees in that state.

Structural barriers, such as broker awareness, remain a challenge. Citing the TASC 2026 Broker ICHRA Survey, the authors note that more than half of benefits brokers have never sold the product, despite employer adoption surpassing 20,000 businesses this year. Furthermore, the model shifts more coverage risk to employees, a concern highlighted by the Employee Benefit Research Institute’s Paul Fronstin. With new CMS guidance expected in late 2026 or early 2027, Wakely plans to conduct a follow-up analysis once the rules are finalized.

For insurance professionals and employers, these findings underscore the necessity of granular, state-specific financial modeling when evaluating CHOICE arrangements. As regulatory guidance evolves and market conditions shift, stakeholders should monitor how vendor fees and risk pool dynamics influence the long-term sustainability of these plans in their specific jurisdictions.

Why it matters

The report demonstrates that CHOICE arrangements are not a universal cost-saving solution, as their viability is heavily influenced by state-specific premium differences, administrative fees, and potential impacts on risk pool stability.

FAQ

What is a CHOICE arrangement?
Formerly known as an ICHRA, a CHOICE arrangement allows employers to fund individual reimbursement accounts that employees use to purchase coverage on the ACA marketplace instead of using a traditional group plan.

Why might vendor fees affect CHOICE adoption?
In markets where individual and small group ACA premiums are similar, vendor fees—modeled at $50 per employee per month—can eliminate the premium savings advantage, making the arrangement uncompetitive.

How does CHOICE impact the individual ACA risk pool?
The impact depends on the relative health of the populations; if healthier employer groups join, the risk pool may improve, but if they choose other alternatives, the pool could deteriorate, potentially increasing premiums for all individual enrollees.

Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.