eBay Insurance Claim Denied for $55.7M Harassment Settlement
ACE Property & Casualty Insurance Co. has filed a federal suit in California asking a judge to rule that eBay does not qualify for coverage under its excess commercial umbrella policy for the $55.7 million settlement of a civil case brought by Massachusetts bloggers Ina and David Steiner. The insurer argues that the losses stemmed from willful, intentional acts by eBay executives and employees, which are excluded under the policy’s provisions for expected or intended wrongdoing.
The policy in question provides limits of fifty million dollars per occurrence and fifty million dollars in aggregate, covering bodily injury, property damage and personal injury arising from an “occurrence” during the policy period. ACE contends that the harassment campaign was a deliberate, criminal act, falling squarely within the policy’s exclusion for expected or intended injury and for personal injury committed with knowledge of rights violations.
The Steiners, publishers of the trade newsletter EcommerceBytes, alleged that eBay security staff bombarded them with vulgar messages, mailed live spiders, a bloody pig mask and a funeral wreath, and physically stalked them for two weeks after former CEO Devin Wenig criticized Ina Steiner’s reporting. Internal communications cited by ACE show Wenig urging a communications chief to “take her down” after a critical article about an eBay-Amazon lawsuit, prompting the chief’s reply, “On it.” The campaign escalated in August 2019, including attempts to install a GPS tracker on the Steiners’ vehicle, which led to police involvement and an FBI investigation.
In July 2021 the Steiners filed a lawsuit accusing eBay and its senior leaders of stalking, intentional infliction of emotional distress, civil rights violations, trespassing, vandalism, civil conspiracy and tortious interference. The case settled in June 2026. Under the settlement, the Steiners receive $48.7 million in compensation—$46.15 million from eBay, $2 million from former CEO Wenig and $550,000 from two other senior former executives. eBay also agreed to fund $6 million in charitable contributions, while Wenig pledged an additional $1 million to a First Amendment-focused charity.
ACE further alleges that eBay breached its insurance contract by settling without the insurer’s consent, failing to provide required information for claim evaluation, and not allocating the settlement between compensatory and punitive damages. The insurer also points to California law prohibiting coverage for losses caused by an insured’s deliberate misconduct. Seven members of eBay’s security team later pleaded guilty to federal crimes related to the harassment, and eBay entered a deferred prosecution agreement, admitting responsibility for the actions of its officers and agreeing to a $3 million criminal penalty.
The insurer’s filing emphasizes that the conduct was not the work of a few rogue managers but involved senior management, including the CEO, who directed and endorsed the campaign. ACE seeks a declaratory judgment that the policy does not obligate it to indemnify eBay or the individual executives for the settlement and related penalties.
Why it matters
The case highlights the limits of corporate liability insurance when misconduct is intentional, a key risk factor for insurers and large tech firms.
FAQ
What amount is eBay seeking to avoid paying under its insurance policy?
eBay is seeking to avoid coverage for the $55.7 million settlement with the Steiners.
Why does ACE claim the policy does not cover the settlement?
ACE argues the losses were expected or intended and resulted from deliberate misconduct, which the policy excludes.
What were the components of the Steiners' settlement?
The settlement includes $46.15 million from eBay, $2 million from former CEO Devin Wenig, $550,000 from two other former executives, $6 million in charitable contributions from eBay, and a $1 million pledge from Wenig.
Source: Insurance Journal. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone