Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurementsCooking

SMAR Daily Industry News

Daily news across AI, technology, finance, insurance, healthcare, automotive, real estate, and government

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

WV Court Voids Milbank UIM Restriction in Fatal Crash Case

šŸ“… 2026-11-17 | šŸ“° Insurance Business America
#west virginia #insurance law #uim coverage #milbank insurance #liability

The West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals has issued a ruling that invalidates a specific policy clause used by Milbank Insurance Company to deny underinsured motorist (UIM) benefits. The court determined that a vehicle does not need to be involved in an accident to qualify as an underinsured motor vehicle under state law, effectively rejecting policy language that attempted to impose such a requirement.

The legal dispute originated from a fatal wrong-way collision on November 23, 2019, on Ohio State Route 7. Caleb Ratcliffe was driving a Hyundai Accent owned by passenger Sierra Mattson when the vehicle collided head-on with another car. Both Ratcliffe and Mattson were among the five individuals who died in the crash. Following the incident, the estate of a deceased passenger pursued compensation. While the estate secured $120,000 from pooled liability proceeds—drawn from policies that each carried limits of $100,000 per person and $300,000 per accident—it sought additional UIM benefits under Mattson’s Milbank policy.

The estate’s claim hinged on a separate vehicle owned by Ratcliffe, which was parked at his home and uninvolved in the collision. The estate argued that because Ratcliffe owned a vehicle with liability insurance that proved insufficient to cover the damages, the parked car qualified as an underinsured vehicle. Milbank contested this, citing a policy endorsement requiring that liability must arise from the ownership, maintenance, or use of the underinsured vehicle itself.

While the Intermediate Court of Appeals initially sided with the insurer, the state Supreme Court reversed that decision on November 13, 2026. The high court held that Milbank’s endorsement was more restrictive than the state’s UIM statute and therefore unenforceable. The court emphasized that West Virginia law requires UIM coverage to be interpreted liberally to ensure full compensation for injured parties. Chief Justice Bunn and Justice Trump dissented from the majority opinion.

The case has been remanded to the lower court to address remaining issues. These include allegations that Milbank’s UIM selection forms were defective, which could potentially raise coverage to the liability limits rather than the policy's stated UIM limits of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident. Other outstanding claims, such as bad faith and unfair settlement practices, also remain unresolved.

For insurance carriers and claims departments, this decision serves as a clear signal that policy language attempting to restrict UIM eligibility based on a vehicle's physical involvement in an accident will not withstand judicial scrutiny in West Virginia, necessitating a review of similar endorsements.

Why it matters

This ruling limits the ability of insurers to restrict UIM coverage, potentially increasing liability exposure by decoupling coverage eligibility from a vehicle's direct involvement in an accident.

FAQ

Why did the estate claim UIM benefits for a parked car?
The estate argued that the driver, Caleb Ratcliffe, owned a vehicle with liability coverage that was insufficient, and state law does not require that vehicle to be involved in the accident to trigger UIM status.

What was the specific policy restriction Milbank used?
Milbank’s endorsement required that the owner’s liability must arise out of the ownership, maintenance, or use of the underinsured vehicle, effectively tying coverage to the vehicle's involvement in the crash.

What happens next in the case?
The case has been remanded to the lower court to address outstanding claims, including allegations of defective UIM selection forms and potential bad faith or unfair settlement practices.

Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.