Behavioral Plan Design Boosts Retirement Savings
A retrospective analysis by Voya Financial’s Behavioral Finance Institute for Innovation indicates that retirement plan design often outweighs participant effort in determining savings outcomes. The study, which tracked 310,931 participants across 877 plans between December 2017 and June 2026, found that behaviorally designed plans—those utilizing automatic enrollment and automatic escalation—consistently outperformed traditional plan structures.
Participants in plans featuring both automatic enrollment and automatic escalation saw their average savings rates improve by 3.56 percentage points, more than double the 1.64-point gain observed in traditional plans. The disparity was most pronounced among non-digitally engaged participants. Those who never logged in, reviewed projections, or adjusted contributions saw their savings rates rise by 4.09 percentage points in behaviorally designed plans, compared to just 0.99 percentage points in traditional plans.
While plan design drives progress, digital engagement also increased during the study period, rising from 57.5% of participants in 2017 to 76.1% in 2026. Digitally engaged participants in behaviorally informed plans achieved savings rates exceeding 11% of pay by 2026, with account balances growing by 234%, compared to 201% for engaged participants in traditional plans. Voya noted that market returns influenced these balance figures.
Despite these outcomes, adoption of these features remains limited. Gallagher’s 2026 US Benefits Strategy and Benchmarking Survey of 3,717 organizations reports that only 57% of employers use auto-enrollment and 33% utilize auto-escalation. Furthermore, Vanguard’s 2026 data indicates that 38% of auto-enrollment plans set initial contributions below 4%.
For employers and plan sponsors, this data suggests that relying on employee initiative may be insufficient for achieving retirement readiness. As regulatory mandates like SECURE 2.0 increasingly require automatic enrollment, plan sponsors may need to focus on optimizing default contribution rates and escalation features to ensure meaningful long-term growth for their workforce.
Why it matters
The findings highlight that structural plan design, rather than employee engagement, is the primary driver of retirement savings progress, suggesting a shift in how employers should structure benefits to ensure better outcomes.
FAQ
How much did savings rates improve for non-engaged participants in behaviorally designed plans?
Non-digitally engaged participants in plans with both automatic enrollment and automatic escalation saw their savings rates improve by 4.09 percentage points.
What percentage of employers currently use automatic escalation in their retirement plans?
According to Gallagher’s 2026 US Benefits Strategy and Benchmarking Survey, 33% of employers use automatic escalation.
Did market returns impact the account balance growth noted in the study?
Yes, Voya noted that market returns contributed to balance growth for both digitally engaged groups, so the figures are not solely a result of plan design.
Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone