Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

SMAR Daily Industry News

Daily news across AI, technology, finance, insurance, healthcare, automotive, real estate, and government

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

UnitedHealth Owe $192M in 2024 Group MLR Rebates

📅 2026-11-16 | 📰 Insurance Business America
#mlr rebates #unitedhealth group #cms 2024 data #group health insurance #planlined analysis

Health insurers reported a total of $460 million in federal medical loss ratio (MLR) rebates for the 2024 reporting year across small and large group markets. This figure is based on an analysis by Planlined, a benefits proposal software company for employee benefits brokers, which examined the CMS 2024 MLR public use file published on November 14. The data is drawn directly from insurer submissions to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and is independently verifiable against the agency’s published records. The group market total consists of $274 million in small group rebates and $185.9 million in large group rebates, according to CMS’s published state summary figures.

UnitedHealth Group, filing as UNITEDHEALTH GRP, owed the largest rebates in both market segments. The company was responsible for $94.2 million in small group rebates across 29 state filings and $98 million in large group rebates across 27 state filings. Elevance Health was the second-largest payer in the small group market with $77.3 million, while Independence Blue Cross Group ranked second in the large group market with $20.6 million. These individual issuer figures are verifiable against the CMS public use file, though parent-company aggregations reflect Planlined’s grouping of related legal entities.

The distribution of rebates varies significantly by state. Massachusetts led the small group market with $54.4 million, driven largely by Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts and Mass General Brigham Health Plan. In the large group market, Pennsylvania led with $27.1 million, with Independence Assurance Company and Highmark Group as the principal contributors. Thirteen states and territories, including Alaska, North Dakota, and West Virginia, had no rebates in either group market.

Rebates indicate that a carrier’s pooled three-year ratio in a specific state and market fell below the MLR standard, which is 80% for small group and 85% for large group plans, measured over 2022 through 2024. This metric reflects the carrier’s entire book of business in that region, not the claims experience of any individual employer. However, it provides documented context for renewal conversations, particularly when a carrier proposes significant rate increases, such as the median 14% increase requested for small group plans in 2027, while simultaneously returning premium due to a shortfall in their loss ratio.

MLR rules apply only to fully insured arrangements. Self-funded plans, including most level-funded structures, do not file MLR reports and owe no rebates regardless of their loss ratios. This distinction is becoming more relevant as margin compression pushes more mid-market employers to evaluate funding alternatives at renewal. Planlined offers two free downloads from the analysis: a state and market CSV covering all 56 jurisdictions in the CMS file, and an issuer CSV listing every filing that owed a rebate with its NAIC company code. The issuer file is a practical starting point because rebates attach to the legal entity that issued the policy, which can vary by state even under the same parent brand.

Planlined noted a $5.5 million difference between its public use file totals and CMS’s own published state summary PDF, concentrated in a small number of state and market cells. The company reports the insurer filing figures as submitted without adjusting toward CMS’s summary, and CMS has not published an explanation for this discrepancy. The full CMS 2024 MLR public use file is available from the Center for Consumer Information and Insurance Oversight.

Why it matters

This data provides brokers and employers with verifiable evidence of insurer underperformance in specific states, which can be used to negotiate rates during the 2026 and 2027 renewal cycles.

FAQ

Which company owed the largest MLR rebates in 2024?
UnitedHealth Group owed the largest rebates, with $94.2 million in small group and $98 million in large group markets.

What is the total amount of group MLR rebates reported for 2024?
Health insurers reported a total of $460 million in federal MLR rebates across small and large group markets for the 2024 reporting year.

Do self-funded plans owe MLR rebates?
No, MLR rules apply only to fully insured arrangements. Self-funded plans, including most level-funded structures, do not file MLR reports and owe no rebates.

Which state had the highest small group MLR rebates?
Massachusetts led the small group market with $54.4 million in rebates.

Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.