Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

SMAR Daily Industry News

Daily news across AI, technology, finance, insurance, healthcare, automotive, real estate, and government

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

US Liability Claims Surge Due to Legal System Abuse

📅 2026-11-13 | 📰 Insurance Business America
#liability insurance #claim severity #litigation funding #triple-i #insurance costs

A recent study from the Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I) highlights a significant trend in the US insurance market: litigation-driven claim costs are outpacing general economic inflation. Between 2016 and 2025, insurers across four major liability lines absorbed between $274.8 billion and $337 billion in excess losses. This figure represents roughly 16% to 19.6% of total booked losses, costs that Triple-I attributes to legal system abuse rather than standard economic factors.

The industry defines legal system abuse as a combination of litigation tactics, the presence of third-party litigation funding, and jury awards that exceed the underlying value of the claims. According to Triple-I CEO Sean Kevelighan, this phenomenon is creating sustained pressure on insurance affordability for both businesses and consumers. The report emphasizes that the primary driver of these costs is claim severity, not claim frequency.

The product liability segment has experienced the most dramatic impact, with claim severity increasing at an annual rate of 22.8% since 2016. By 2025, excess costs in this category accounted for approximately 51.5% of all booked losses. Meanwhile, commercial auto liability saw additional costs ranging from $60.8 billion to $86 billion, with claim severity growing at a compound annual rate of 8.2% despite claim frequency remaining below pre-pandemic levels.

Other segments are also feeling the strain. General liability and premises-related claims recorded the highest dollar impact, with additional costs totaling between $106.7 billion and $125 billion. Personal auto liability bodily injury claims are currently 62.4% higher than pre-pandemic levels, resulting in estimated additional losses between $101.6 billion and $120.1 billion.

In response to these rising costs, insurance brokers are advising clients to adjust their strategies. Lockton’s July 2026 update suggests that buyers should prioritize early engagement and robust data when approaching renewals. For lines experiencing rapid severity growth—specifically product liability, commercial auto, and umbrella coverage—brokers recommend reviewing deductibles, program structures, and attachment points. Matthew Hannon of Aon noted that this is a systemic shift, meaning organizations of all sizes must rethink how they approach casualty risk.

Legislative efforts to address these costs are underway, with several states enacting reforms. Georgia, Mississippi, and Tennessee have mandated the disclosure of third-party litigation funding since early 2025, while North Carolina prohibited such funding in its court system in June 2026. At the federal level, the Litigation Funding Transparency Act of 2026 was introduced in February by Senators Chuck Grassley, Thom Tillis, John Kennedy, and John Cornyn, though it remains in committee. Despite these developments, industry experts caution that buyers should not anticipate immediate relief in pricing or capacity as social inflation and large verdicts continue to influence the market.

Why it matters

For insurance buyers and stakeholders, this trend signals that rising litigation costs are a systemic issue that may necessitate structural changes to insurance programs, regardless of broader market conditions.

FAQ

What is the primary driver of rising liability costs according to Triple-I?
The primary driver is claim severity, which is being fueled by legal system abuse, including litigation tactics, third-party funding, and outsized jury awards.

Which liability line has seen the highest growth in claim severity?
Product liability occurrence has seen the sharpest growth, with claim severity rising at an annual rate of 22.8% since 2016.

Have legislative actions successfully lowered insurance costs yet?
No. While several states have enacted reforms and federal legislation has been introduced, brokers warn that buyers should not expect these measures to quickly reverse pricing or capacity pressures.

Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.